The Dangote Group has experienced a decline in its stock prices, with its sugar and food subsidiaries facing significant challenges. The decline in stock prices for Dangote Sugar Refinery and NASCON Allied Industries is primarily attributed to foreign exchange losses and the rejection of a proposed merger by the Securities and Exchange Commission.
Analysts blamed the escalating inflation and unstable exchange rate for worsening the companies’ predicament. The rising cost of imported raw materials due to currency depreciation has significantly squeezed profit margins.
Dangote Sugar Refinery’s stock price plummeted by 18.67%, dropping from N45.00 to N36.60 from May to August 2024. This decline was driven by disruptions in the supply chain and volatile sugar prices, which adversely impacted the company’s financial performance.
During the same period, NASCON Allied Industries also experienced a downturn in its stock price, falling by 12.57% from N37.00 to N32.45. In contrast, Dangote Cement achieved a remarkable 41% growth in its share price, rising from N419 in May and reaching N591 by early August.
In a statement dated April and signed by the company secretary of NASCON, Adedayo Samuel, it was stated that the proposed merger with Dangote Sugar Refinery Plc and Dangote Rice Limited has been suspended.
He added that this decision, initially announced on August 30, 2023, will not proceed following the comments and recommendations from the Securities and Exchange Commission, which highlighted concerns regarding the current non-operational status of Dangote Rice Limited. NASCON expressed gratitude to its stakeholders for their continued support.
“NASCON Allied Industries Plc. (“NASCON”) at this moment notifies the Nigerian Exchange Limited and the investing public that, further to its announcement of August 30, 2023, in respect of the proposed merger of Dangote Sugar Refinery Plc, NASCON, and Dangote Rice Limited, a decision has been taken to suspend the said merger at this time.
“The suspension is due to the comments and recommendations of the Securities and Exchange Commission centered around the current non-operational status of Dangote Rice Limited. NASCON wishes to express its appreciation to all its stakeholders and will keep the public informed of any developments as they arise.”
A shareholders’ advocacy group leader, Bisi Bakare, stated that while Dangote Group’s subsidiaries have faced declines, they are actively seeking growth opportunities and resilience.
“I do not think the refinery is playing any role in it. It has to do with similar challenges facing the manufacturing sector.
One of the challenges is the effect of foreign exchange losses, which arose as a result of the continuous depreciation of the naira.
“Also, inflationary pressures, which arose as a result of a continuous increase in inflation, led to a high interest rate on borrowing, which has an untold effect on finance costs and the bottom line. Also, the high cost of raw materials imported and the high cost of energy. All these factors continue to impact the manufacturing sector, of which Dangote Cement isn’t an exception,” she said.
A financial analyst, Ariyo Olugbosun, attributed the decline to the Securities and Exchange Commission’s denial of a proposed merger involving Dangote Sugar, NASCON, and Dangote Rice Limited. Olugbosun argued that the regulatory decision led to a loss of investor interest, exacerbating the stock price fluctuations.
“While FX losses are a concern, the SEC’s decision on the merger has been a major driver behind the fluctuating stock prices. The SEC decision is best known to them, but I think it would have helped Dangote make more profit,” Olugbosun explained.
In response to concerns about the price of Dangote Cement, the President of the Progressives Shareholders Association of Nigeria, Boniface Okezie, emphasized that the fluctuations were largely driven by market forces, adding that this perspective underscores the broader trends affecting the entire sector, not just individual players.
“The trend is not unique to Dangote Cement alone. If you look at other companies in the cement industry, like BUA Cement and Lafarge, you’ll see similar patterns. Despite the challenges, Dangote Cement remains higher in value compared to its peers, with BUA Cement following closely.”
Regarding Dangote’s much-anticipated refinery project, Boniface noted that its performance cannot be assessed at this time as it is not yet a publicly quoted company, emphasizing the need for swift action to prevent further damage to the oil and gas industry.
“The refinery isn’t fully operational, and until it is, we can’t gauge its market strength,” Boniface explained. They blamed ongoing challenges with the NNPC and other regulatory agencies for hindering progress. “Nigeria stands to lose if the regulatory relationships aren’t quickly resolved.”
Boniface expressed worry that the ongoing issues could scare away foreign investors from engaging with Nigeria. “A lot of investors might shy away from doing business here”.
He urged for a swift resolution to maintain Nigeria’s attractiveness to international investors, stating, “We urge him not to lose faith in the Nigerian economy. Though the journey might not be easy, his massive investments will yield benefits once the challenges are resolved. It’s a long-term investment, and he won’t reap the rewards immediately, but he will in time,” Boniface added.
This article was written by Tamaraebiju Jide, a student at Elizade University
